Difference between `systemd-resolved` and `dnsmasq`

Difference between systemd-resolved and dnsmasq

Both systemd-resolved and dnsmasq are DNS services, but they serve different purposes and are often used in different contexts.


1. systemd-resolved

Purpose:

  • DNS Resolution : systemd-resolved is primarily a local DNS resolver that provides network name resolution to applications running on your machine. It integrates closely with the systemd suite of tools.
  • NetworkManager Integration : It works with NetworkManager and other network configuration tools to provide per-interface DNS settings, supporting scenarios where different network interfaces (e.g., Wi-Fi, Ethernet, VPN) may require different DNS servers.
  • DNS Caching : Provides basic DNS caching but is not as advanced as dnsmasq in terms of caching capabilities.
  • DNS over TLS (DoT): Supports DNS over TLS for encrypted DNS queries, improving privacy and security by encrypting DNS queries between your system and the DNS server.

Common Use Cases:

  • Desktop environments: Often used in Linux desktop distributions like Ubuntu, where you need automatic handling of DNS when switching between networks.
  • Simple DNS resolution for local applications.

Limitations:

  • Basic DNS features : systemd-resolved is mainly a simple DNS resolver and lacks advanced features like DHCP support or extensive DNS customization.
  • Limited caching: Basic caching compared to dedicated DNS services.

2. dnsmasq

Purpose:

  • DNS Caching : dnsmasq is a lightweight DNS forwarder and caching server. It caches DNS queries for faster responses to repeated requests.
  • DHCP Server : It also functions as a DHCP server, providing IP addresses to devices in a local network. This makes it popular for use in small home or office networks where you want a lightweight DHCP and DNS service.
  • TFTP Server: Supports TFTP (Trivial File Transfer Protocol), often used in network booting.
  • Custom DNS Configuration : dnsmasq allows for more granular DNS configurations, such as defining specific IP addresses for domain names, managing custom DNS routes, or forwarding certain DNS queries to specific DNS servers.

Common Use Cases:

  • Small or medium networks: Often used as a DNS and DHCP server for home networks, offices, or small cloud setups.
  • DNS caching for faster lookups: Caching speeds up DNS resolution for frequent queries.
  • VPNs: Commonly used in conjunction with VPNs to provide DNS resolution and IP management for VPN clients.
  • Routers and embedded systems: Frequently found in embedded devices like routers, where lightweight services are crucial.

Limitations:

  • No DNS over TLS: Does not natively support DNS over TLS, although it can be combined with other services to achieve this.

Key Differences:

Feature systemd-resolved dnsmasq
DNS Forwarding Yes Yes
DNS Caching Basic More advanced
DHCP Server No Yes
NetworkManager Integration Strong integration with NetworkManager Not tightly integrated
DNS over TLS (DoT) Yes No
Configuration Automatically configured for per-interface DNS Highly customizable for DNS and DHCP
Primary Use Local DNS resolution on desktops DNS and DHCP services for small networks, VPNs, etc.
TFTP Support No Yes

When to use each:

  • Use systemd-resolved when you need a basic DNS resolver integrated with system tools like NetworkManager, especially in desktop environments where per-interface DNS handling is important.

  • Use dnsmasq when you need a lightweight DNS server with advanced DNS caching and DHCP services, particularly in network or server environments (like home networks, small offices, VPNs, or cloud setups).

You can even use both services together, with dnsmasq providing advanced DNS and DHCP functionality and systemd-resolved handling DNS resolution locally on your machine.

相关推荐
序属秋秋秋1 小时前
《Linux系统编程之入门基础》【Linux基础 理论+命令】(上)
linux·运维·服务器·ubuntu·centos·命令模式
知白守黑2673 小时前
docker资源限制
运维·docker·容器
霍格沃兹测试开发学社测试人社区3 小时前
新手指南:通过 Playwright MCP Server 为 AI Agent 实现浏览器自动化能力
运维·人工智能·自动化
ximy13354 小时前
AI服务器工作之服务器的种类分类
运维·服务器
恒创科技HK4 小时前
香港服务器CPU中E5和Gold的区别
运维·服务器
Wang's Blog6 小时前
Linux小课堂: 文件操作警惕高危删除命令与深入文件链接机制
linux·运维·服务器
2501_915909068 小时前
iOS 混淆实战,多工具组合完成 IPA 混淆与加固(源码 + 成品 + 运维一体化方案)
android·运维·ios·小程序·uni-app·iphone·webview
我科绝伦(Huanhuan Zhou)8 小时前
分享一个可以一键制作在线yum源的脚本
linux·运维
爱宇阳8 小时前
禅道社区版 Docker Compose 服务迁移教程
运维·docker·容器
Paper_Love9 小时前
Linux-查看硬件接口软件占用
linux·运维·服务器