FPGA Prototyping vs Emulation

FPGA Prototyping vs. Emulation

One way to visualize the difference between Prototyping and Emulation is with a "spider chart" (named for its resemblance to a spider's web). The Prototyping vs. Emulation spider chart below highlights the differences between these two verification methods, which may be summarized as runtime speed, design capacity, and affordability -- all other differences, sometimes not insignificant, are "artifacts" of these three fundamental differences. Compilation speed is a function of design capacity -- the larger the design the longer the compilation time. Any simulator can be connected in-circuit to a hardware target system with the appropriate speed-buffers but the verification runtime speed is still limited by the simulation platform -- Emulation runtime speed is much faster than software simulation, and achievable Prototyping runtime speeds are much higher than Emulation runtime speeds. Likewise, any simulator can be used for software debug for periods of software execution -- the higher runtime speeds of Prototyping enable much longer periods of software execution therefor longer software debug sessions. And debug visibility could include every internal design node in a Prototype or Emulator -- but each design node probe is another internal wire connection in FPGA-based Prototyping and Emulation implementations, which impacts design capacity and runtime speed. Finally, reusability is a function of the customization of the Prototyping or Emulation platform needed to achieve the verification design capacity and runtime speed goals -- the more customized the platform is for the specific verification requirements, the less reusable it will be. The underlying Prototyping or Emulation hardware itself is infinitely reusable, but the design compilations, IP block adaptations, and external connections will have limited reusability.

What Can FPGA Prototyping or Emulation Do Best for You?

To summarize, FPGA Prototyping today is generally more affordable than Emulation, it can achieve much higher runtime speeds, and design capacity has been greatly expanded by today's leading-edge FPGA technology. Emulation, on the other hand comes with a higher cost of ownership, provides more simulation-like verification for design debug. In fact, if you can afford both Prototyping and Emulation, debug with Prototyping is usually limited to identifying and isolating design hardware/software problems over long periods of design operation which are then reproduced in Emulation for detailed debug. It is recommended that you be clear about your verification goals and priorities, you consider the skill set of your design team with respect to getting the best value from Prototyping and/or Emulation, do a quick ROI calculation on your verification tool investment, budget accordingly -- and only then proceed with a choice and deployment of FPGA Prototyping and/or Emulation.

S2C Can Help

S2C is a leading global supplier of FPGA prototyping solutions for today's innovative SoC and ASIC designs, now with the second largest share of the global prototyping market. S2C has been successfully delivering rapid SoC prototyping solutions since 2003. With over 500 customers, including 6 of the world's top 15 semiconductor companies, our world-class engineering team and customer-centric sales team are experts at addressing our customer's SoC and ASIC verification needs. S2C has offices and sales representatives in the US, Europe, mainland China, Hong Kong, Korea, and Japan.

相关推荐
bnsarocket5 小时前
Verilog和FPGA的自学笔记1——FPGA
笔记·fpga开发·verilog·自学
最遥远的瞬间8 小时前
一、通用的FPGA开发流程介绍
fpga开发
weixin_4509072810 小时前
第八章 FPGA 片内 FIFO 读写测试实验
fpga开发
cycf15 小时前
以太网接口(一)
fpga开发
nnerddboy1 天前
FPGA自学笔记(正点原子ZYNQ7020):1.Vivado软件安装与点灯
笔记·fpga开发
li星野2 天前
打工人日报#20251005
笔记·程序人生·fpga开发·学习方法
通信小呆呆2 天前
FPGA 上的 OFDM 同步:从 S&C 到残差 CFO 的工程化实现
fpga开发·信号处理·同步·ofdm
hahaha60163 天前
高层次综合基础-vivado hls第三章
算法·fpga开发
XINVRY-FPGA5 天前
XCVU9P-2FLGA2104E Xilinx AMD Virtex UltraScale+ FPGA
人工智能·嵌入式硬件·fpga开发·硬件工程·dsp开发·射频工程·fpga
范纹杉想快点毕业6 天前
ZYNQ7045芯片中UART实现RS422通信详解,50000字解析,C语言,嵌入式开发,软件开发
c语言·笔记·stm32·单片机·嵌入式硬件·mcu·fpga开发